Province seeks new power over crime-linked property
Newfoundland and Labrador has introduced legislation that would allow the province to pursue the seizure of property connected to criminal activity, even when the person linked to the assets has not been convicted of an offence. Justice Minister Helen Conway Ottenheimer presented the proposed law Tuesday in St. John’s, saying the measure is intended to remove the financial benefit of criminal conduct.
The bill, titled An Act Respecting Civil Forfeiture of Property, would create civil forfeiture powers in a province that is currently one of only two in Canada without such legislation. Prince Edward Island is the other. Provinces including Ontario and British Columbia have used civil-forfeiture laws for more than two decades, according to the source material.
“At its core, this legislation is about ensuring crime does not pay,” Conway Ottenheimer told reporters.
Rather than focusing exclusively on prosecuting an individual, civil forfeiture proceedings target property or proceeds alleged to be associated with unlawful activity. The proposed Newfoundland and Labrador framework would use the civil court system, where the government would have to establish the connection on a balance of probabilities. That threshold is lower than the criminal-law requirement of proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
How the proposed approach would differ
The legislation would therefore make the status of a criminal prosecution relevant, but not necessarily decisive, to an effort to take property. The government’s stated objective is to pursue assets themselves. Under the proposal, the absence of a conviction would not automatically prevent the province from seeking forfeiture if it could meet the civil evidentiary standard.
| Issue | Proposed approach |
|---|---|
| Type of proceeding | Civil court process |
| Property at issue | Assets associated with criminal activity |
| Required standard | Balance of probabilities |
| Criminal conviction required | No |
The proposal places Newfoundland and Labrador alongside most other provinces in adopting a tool that governments describe as a way to disrupt the economic foundations of crime. At the same time, the distinction between civil and criminal proceedings is central: forfeiture would concern ownership or control of property, while criminal charges require proof of an offence and guilt to the higher criminal standard.
Example cited by the government
The government pointed to the case of Kurt Churchill in explaining the type of property that could draw attention under a civil-forfeiture system. Churchill was accused of shooting and killing 47-year-old James Coady outside his home on Craigmillar Avenue in St. John’s in 2020. Police searching Churchill’s home found $435,000 in cash, according to the source material.
The available account does not provide the outcome of the proposed legislation or describe any forfeiture proceeding involving that money. It does, however, illustrate the government’s focus on assets that investigators believe may be connected to serious criminal activity. If passed, the bill would give Newfoundland and Labrador a new civil-law mechanism for pursuing such property, while cases would turn on the evidence presented and the balance-of-probabilities test.
- The legislation was introduced by Justice Minister Helen Conway Ottenheimer.
- Newfoundland and Labrador is one of two provinces without civil-forfeiture legislation.
- The proposed process would not require a criminal conviction and would use a civil standard of proof.