Plans to install a CT scanner at Kings County Memorial Hospital in Montague, P.E.I., are being reassessed after the province’s health minister said some front-line staff have questioned whether the equipment is necessary.
Health and Wellness Minister Cory Deagle made the comments as the proposal came under scrutiny in the P.E.I. Legislature. The project had previously been presented as an important investment for the hospital and was included in the province’s capital budget last year, according to Opposition Leader Hal Perry.
Opposition challenges the change
Perry, who represents the opposition, criticized the government during question period on Thursday. He said the scanner had been promised and approved, and accused the government of mishandling health-care planning in rural communities. Perry also said the concern extended beyond the Montague hospital.
“The CT scanners were promised. They were in capital budget last year. They were approved and now he's saying they're not going to get them?”
The opposition leader described himself as “so angry” and said the government had a record of reducing health services for Islanders living outside the province’s main urban centre. Those statements are political criticism; the available information does not establish whether the project will ultimately be cancelled or whether another plan will be adopted.
What is being reviewed
A CT scanner uses X-rays to produce detailed images inside the body. The source material says the technology can assist in diagnosing conditions including blood clots and cancer. The equipment can therefore be relevant to decisions about how hospitals organize diagnostic services, but the reports do not provide an assessment of projected demand, staffing requirements, operating costs or travel times for patients.
- Facility: Kings County Memorial Hospital in Montague, eastern P.E.I.
- Decision status: Plans for the scanner are being reviewed.
- Government position reported: Some front-line staff have said the equipment may not be needed.
- Political response: Opposition Leader Hal Perry says the approved project should proceed.
Implications remain unresolved
The disagreement illustrates the competing questions involved in rural health-care planning: whether specialized equipment should be located closer to smaller communities, and whether a hospital can sustain the staff and services required to use it. In this case, the government’s review appears to be focused on whether the scanner is needed at Kings County Memorial, while the opposition is framing the issue as part of a wider pattern affecting rural access.
The source material does not identify a final decision, a replacement for the proposed scanner or a timetable for the review. It also does not say which front-line staff raised concerns or provide a response from hospital users. Until the province completes its assessment, it remains unclear whether the Montague project will proceed as planned, be modified or be shelved.